The Outsider

I am the outsider. I can’t speak for David if he feels it as well but I most definitely feel out of place. Like I don’t belong. I’m there but not fully participating. In life, in gatherings. Not by the fault of anyone else. It just is. I am the outsider in my family. They always include us, always. And understand when we don’t join. And yet I am on the fringes. Because I am always stained with sadness. I cannot fully revel in the joy or excitement of my surroundings, in the happiness of others. Especially when the whole family is together. Because it’s the whole family minus one. And the missing piece is glaring. When it comes to family gatherings I do much better if it’s just some of us. Ariella’s absence isn’t so obvious. She may or may not have been there when she was still alive. But the whole family, she would be there. And now she’s not. And so rather than being able to enjoy myself my heart is on the one person that should be there but isn’t. It’s too painful to be so aware while seeing the rest of the group smile and laugh and have a great time like everything’s okay. I am the outsider, the downer.

I am an outsider amongst my friends. Especially when in groups. Also through no fault of their own. Inevitably conversation turns to their kids. I don’t mind that. I like hearing about their lives. But I have nothing to contribute. I have no living children and I have no new stories about Ariella to share. I can’t comment on the bitter sweetness of watching our children grow up too quickly. I can’t commiserate about the trying teenage years. I can’t share the excitement of my child’s achievements. Ariella was not my only loss. I also loss my identity as a mother. Yes I’m still a mother. I will always be Ariella’s mother. And yet. I’m not parenting. Plenty of people choose not to have children. This is not the same. Because of the pain that accompanies these situations. Knowing we once had the same promise and hopes and now we don’t.

Even among other bereaved parents I feel like an outsider, except among those that also lost their only child. Those parents still have their purpose. They still get to raise kids, watch them grow up, maintain their identities as parents. As someone who has always had social anxiety, I feel even less able to relate now. It can be a very lonely place. I’ve been doing what I can to keep busy, meet new people, and just stay active. I’ve joined running groups and actually started golf lessons. It’s good for me. Good to be involved in specific activities, to be involved in something that revolves around that activity.

I have found that while my grief has changed, meaning mostly that I’ve learned to live with it and even enjoy myself sometimes, the hurt has actually gotten worse. I’m witnessing Ariella’s friends grow up, her younger friends surpass her and find myself thinking more and more of everything that was lost, the future she will never have, that we will never have. David and I went to a wedding a couple of weeks ago and for the first time I had the parents’ perspective rather than the perspective as a peer. Listening to the father of the bride’s toast and watching the father daughter dance hit me so hard. We will never have that. And in those moments that was all I could think about.

This was a difficult post to write. I’ve had a hard time getting my thoughts together and I still don’t think I’ve captured my true feelings. Someone said to me that she had hoped that I’ve turned a corner in my grief. Not because she thinks I should be “better” but because she doesn’t want to see me in such pain. I feel like I have turned a corner. I do have more moments of fun and I no longer beg to die. I don’t have moments of true happiness and I don’t think I ever will. But I can experience joy and even peace at times. It’s a dichotomy though. I don’t feel guilt, but I don’t understand how I can have those joyful and peaceful moments. It doesn’t feel right. Mostly what I’ve realized is that there is no linear pattern to grief. Just when I think I’m doing okay I’ll have a day or even just a moment that completely disabuses me of that idea, when I think there’s no way that I will make it. I still cannot fathom another lifetime of feeling this way and in fact I dread it, but I also know that somehow I will survive it and will even have some fun along the way.

On a completely unrelated topic, I’ve been pretty vocal about my feelings on signs. I ask for them and have received every sign from Ariella that I have asked for and yet am still cynical that they are just coincidences. I wish I was a true believer. I think that would make life a little easier, knowing she really is there and that we really will be reunited one day. In that sense I am jealous of those that have such a strong faith. That there is no doubt in their minds that they will see their loved ones in the afterlife. But that isn’t me. Yet I continue to ask for signs. I rarely ask my dad for signs but decided I wanted one from him. My dad always used to say “don’t take any wooden nickels” so I asked for a wooden nickel as a sign. It’s not a very common turn of phrase and I don’t think I’ve heard or seen any reference to a wooden nickel since he died. I figured the chances of getting the sign were slim to none. And then this happened…

Also has the word “heaven” Coincidence?

Still not sure what to think but I do like to think that signs are real. So I will continue to ask for them and be skeptical when I receive them!

What do you do when parenting ends?

When a child dies, parents grieve not only the child, but all the missed milestones, big ones as well as those that seemed so unimportant when the child was alive. We don’t just miss our child, her presence, her hugs and her voice. But we miss the future she will never have and the future we will never share. We miss watching her achieve her dreams, become independent, have a family of her own. All the things that make a parent proud, big and little, we grieve. Ariella wanted to achieve so many things. She had so many friends and ideas and activities. We never got to see her become a Bat Mitzvah, learn to drive, have her first date. All the things we were excited for for her. We have watched her friends do some of these things and have seen younger friends surpass her in age and it shatters me every time that we will never get to witness Ariella’s excitement, independence, and growth as she moves forward through the stages of life.

When your only child dies you grieve all of those not just in the context of your child, but in life in general. Not only will we never get to be the proud parents of Ariella as she becomes a Bat Mitzvah, as she tap dances at a dance competition, or watch her walk across the stage in a cap and gown. Not only will we not have the opportunity to panic while teaching her to drive, bemoan an empty nest as we drop her off at college, cry happy tears as we walk her down the aisle, or experience the joy of being grandparents as we babysit her children. We will not get to have these moments ever, at all. We didn’t just lose our daughter. We lost parenthood.

David and I have been trying in several different ways to become parents again for over two years now, and that journey, trek, road, voyage, roller coaster, whatever you want to call it, has officially come to an end. So that’s it. Our parenting experience is over. After just 11 years. Once a parent you are supposed to always be a parent. Watch your child grow to adulthood, not bury your child. I miss Ariella more than words can possibly explain and I miss being a parent just as much. And they are two very separate things. It’s hard enough being forced to live in a world without my daughter in it, but add to that that I am now an outside observer of a life I want so much to be a part of and it is just brutal. No more proud Mama moments. No more perfect fall family outings. No more silly game nights and no more carry-out and movie nights. And I’ll never get to experience what it’s like when your child is an adult, and can be your friend more than your child. Parenting was my life and I’ve had to accept that that part of my life is over. There is no silver lining that accompanies the death of a child. There is no “at least.” But being able to continue to have the parenting experience would have given my life the meaning it is so sorely missing. And the grieving process has started over again with this path definitively coming to an end. I am sad. And lost. And don’t know where to go from here.